As a kid, I remember listening wide-eyed to my grandmother tell me about the “Dummy Room.” The Dummy Room was one of her first assignments as a young teacher in small-town Iowa in the 1930s. Like other Dummy Rooms across the country, it was the dumping ground for the school district’s hard cases.
The Dummy Room was supposed to be just for the “retards,” as they were widely called back then. But as Grandma quickly found out, many of the kids she’d been handed had no mental disabilities at all. Some just needed glasses. Others needed hearing aids. Many improved immediately after a few regular meals and proper grooming.
The road to the Dummy Room left scars on some of those kids. Frustrated (or sadistic) teachers had yelled at them or simply ignored them. Some of the kids had endured corporal punishment when they failed to respond to normal teaching methods. Thank goodness, I’ve often thought, that such treatment is a thing of the past. We now have special education and highly trained teachers. Ours is a more enlightened age.
Well, maybe. You could be excused for thinking otherwise after reading this editorial by U.S. Rep. George Miller, D-Calif., and Rep. Cathy McMorris Rodgers, R-Wash. The piece starts off recounting the terrible story of a Texas boy who died accidentally at the hands of a teacher bent on restraining him. Sadly, Miller and Rodgers point out, there are plenty of other cases like this:
According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, over the last 20 years there have been hundreds of allegations of school personnel using restraint and seclusion in abusive ways on children. It's happening disproportionately to students with disabilities, often at the hands of untrained staff. Many of these students bear haunting physical and emotional scars. And in a number of cases, students have died.
Kids involved in incidents like these are often the toughest or most disruptive students. In many cases, it is easy to see how a teacher might act in self-defense or try to silence a constant source of annoyance. But sometimes that leads to tragic overreactions.
Miller and Rodgers have been pushing to create federal guidelines that would let the states tailor their own specific rules on restraint and seclusion. That seems very reasonable and long overdue.

Comments
When my son was living in
When my son was living in S.C. with his father he suffered abuse from the hands of a teacher and the principal went along with it. Every day he would get a "paddling". Two years later, when he came to GA, they found that he was dyslexic and had a processing disorder. The lasting effect? After having somache aches every day he went to school, he ended up dropping out in the 9th grade and still has trouble holding a job.
I am a teacher, and I see emotional abuse often. But when I stand up for a student, I am ridiculed. Remembering my son, I don't give up.
ijn, Augusta GA
Hearing stuff like this makes
Hearing stuff like this makes me angry, why do people like this want to become teachers and principles? It is sickening to me, my son had a math teacher in 4th grade who picked on him and she was also his tutor as well because he had problems in math, I guess she had no interest in helping him but she did take interest in causing his self esteem to fall by humiliating him in class, every teacher said he was a a joy to have in class and she never made any comments, finally one day after he had enough of her treating him badly and she accused him of cheating when he had not even written anything and the boy behind him was always talking to him the teacher told him to throw his paper away but instead he crumpled it up and threw it at her and left the room crying, needless to say I had had it with this woman and I voiced my opinion and come to find out there were other classes in which she picked out one child who had problems in math to pick on.
This sounds so true. When
This sounds so true. When our daughter was in a first grade she had a teacher who did not like her. This was a totally new experience for our daughter. Our daughter was determined to be student of the month and every month when she did not get the award we would meet with the teacher to review her failings for the month to understand why she did not get the award. Finally in February I bklluntly said just tell me what she has to do and she will do it she really wants to be student of the month. The teacher shook her head and said,"Well as long as she is in my room she will never be student of the month." I thanked her and left. She was one of the school's most highly regarded teachers and I knew goiong to the principal wouldn't change anything. I explained to my daughter that she was not goiong to get an award, but it diddn't have anything to do with her or how well she was working and behaving in class.
Fortunately my daughter had a wonderful 2nd grade teacher who re-ignited her love for school. Our daughter went on to graduate from high school with honors and just recently graduated from the Arizona State University Nursing program as is now a Pediatrics Nurse. Teachers make a difference for better or worse.
I agree. I work with special
I agree. I work with special needs students and have seen how some of the students are treated. It can be hard working with these children but you have to take a break and regroup so that you will not say/do anything stupid.It saddens me because I think about my son and boys in particular how they are treated by teachers. Boys learn differently form girls and tend to have more learning "problems" than girls. Some of the people I work I could lead them to a cliff and throw them off because of their atitudes. I have told the principle and any one who is willing to listen that I want more training if I am to continue working with these students and I think that is one of the problems, training. My degre is in liberal arts and political science but I was offered a position as an aide to a special ed teacher who is not really qualified according to NO CHILD LEFT BEHIND standards. I think one of the problems is the educational system keps telling teachers and college students how much money they can make in the field. I have made plans and have attended graduate classes but it is exspensive and I have two children in college but I feel it is worth it if we really want to help all students.It's time that parents take back the control of their children. Our children's souls do not belong to the state or federal government, the courts,DCFS or the public schools.
Thank you so much for you
Thank you so much for you post. I have endured the same thing and I don't give up. Until parents stop being afraid of this system that cares more about numbers and the teachers than they do parents, it will never change. My son suffered in high school at the hands of football coaches. He uses drugs, was diagnosed with severe depression and prescribed medication. Then the school refused to honor is 504 plan recommendations from his physician for an entire school year. He failed almost all of his classes.
I wrote an editorial in the community newspaper and now I am treated better, but what about the kids that don't have a parent with courage. I just pray and ask God to move those that do not mean our children any good out of the way. I also rally my friends and church members to make a point of caring for all children because we don't know what they go through in school.
I appreciate all the comments
I appreciate all the comments and would never wish for any child to face abuse whether it is physical or emotional abuse from any adult, especially a teacher or teaching staff. However, I am a stay-at-home mother or 2 school-age children who struggled academically because English is not their first language, and were left to fall through the cracks because teachers were so busy attending to the disruptive students in the room. I do not think that one or two students should be allowed to dominate the teacher's time and energy, when so many other students are also deserving of a fair education. I ended up having to transfer my children out of that school and placing them in a charter school, where expectations were clear and distruptive students, whether they had a 504plan/IEP or not were not allowed to ruin other students' chances of getting an education.
Now they are in high school and junior high and are both doing well because the learning environment is safe for all students, not just some. Although, I could have been more insistent with that school, I decided that environment was not the right one for my children if their success had to take a back seat to others.
As an educator, it greatly
As an educator, it greatly saddens me to hear about abuse, exclusion, and continually failing to reach students. That is certainly not why my respected colleagues or I have decided to become educators. If you ask most educators, they will state that they went into education to make a positive difference in the lives of young people in hopes for a more just, fair, and educated society.
I agree that for some educators, this purpose gets lost somewhere along the way. The unfunded mandates, pressures of high stakes testing, and increasingly challenging students makes an educators job extremely difficult. Now, most educators do not resort to abuse, whether it is physical, verbal, or emotional. Many of us simply work harder and longer, still maintaining a positive rapport with our students and finding out what we need to do differently to better reach our students. So in response to the above comment about caring more about teachers and numbers than parents, I would have to agree with that, because it is our job to care about our students, not so much the parents. Controlling numbers and making a positive work environment for the teachers are factors that directly affect our students - those who we are directly serving.
I believe the best scenario for students is for teachers and parents to come together and understand that we might have differing views as to what is best for each individual student. A parent's perspective is often so much more personal and an educator's perspective may be more academically objective. Understanding that both parties have legitimate knowledge about the child to bring to the table in order to best serve the student will warrant the best result.
Let us please hold off the
Let us please hold off the label of the evil educator
who sets expectations and pushes often
manipulative students who seek to disrupt
the environment and process for others.
Johnny has to meet expectations to
earn credit for class or we fail society
by giving away unearned good grades. We
must acknowledge that many of our students
simply do not care to work to learn so
they blame the teacher who challenges
them academically. This is not abuse! Our
society is growing too quick to blame and
not teach. Remember Columbine? A teacher
and students died at the hands of other
students. The tone of this strand is painting
any teacher who challenges students in a
negative light. Do we really want Suzy gaining
unearned good grades so she never faces
the fact her work was under standard. Shall
we sell or give diplomas away just to
protect self esteem? Most students are open
to the learning process and it is wonderful to
see the light bulb switch on! Sadly, an ever
increasing number of kids are not invested
nor do they care that they disrupt and take
away from kids in class who do want to learn.
Noting this fact does not make one an evil teacher.
I think you are missing the
I think you are missing the point.
This is not about students who are apathetic. This is about educators and administrators who cause physical or emotional injury to students, and unfortunately it happens far too frequently, even in this more enlightened day and age. I have been an educator for nearly 30 years, the last 10 of which have been spent as a Behavior Specialist working in urban schools with those "tough kids" everyone makees reference to, and I can tell you that I am far too often deeply disturbed by the negative attitudes and behaviors displayed by some educators and administrators (more often than not they have many, many years in the field). Most educators are wonderful, dedicated and caring professionals who are in the field for the right reasons. But far too many are frustrated, jaded, or simply apathetic themselves, and they can cause lasting damage to the young, malleable minds in their charge. This is a problem that needs to be put out on the table and dealt with by the public so it can once and for all become a practice of the past.
well said. I completely
well said. I completely agree with you. I teach preschool in a very poor urban area and am repeatedly shocked by the number of children attending school for the first time, who are labelled as having a behavioral disability (nearly all boys of color) within a few months of the school year. Many teachers make comments about the children and/or the parents and treat the child disrespectfully and then claim the child is the problem.
I believe you are missing the
I believe you are missing the point of most of the above posts. Yes, some of the children we are referring to may not be working hard at school, but many of the children struggle because of a disability or a different learning style or have a teacher who really doesn't like them (yes, it happens). And why aren't some children working hard or caring about school? When children come to preschool or kindergarten they are excited to be in school. What happens to cause some children to dislike school? Having high expectations is important for all children, but we as teachers have to figure out how to reach the child too. Unfortunately, as a teacher, I do see some of my colleagues abuse children emotionally or physically- usually unintentionally, but still it happens. Our public schools offer an education to ALL children. The ones who learn easily with traditional methods and the ones who have difficulty learning for one reason or another. It is usually these children that are abused. Often teachers become frustrated because they can't figure out how the child learns best or because the child presents with difficult behaviors. Many children have extremely complicated lives, and young children especially have a difficult time having the language to express their feelings. Behavior is a child's form of communication. A baby cries to tell you they are hungry or hurting. An older child who has not found crying to be effective in getting his needs met, may yell or hit to show adults that he needs help. When teachers cannot determine what message the child is trying to convey, they often feel the need to stop the behavior with timeouts or restraint which often leads to more aggressive behavior. In reality, a hug may be what the child really needs.
I believe that virtually all teachers want what is best for students, but may fail students when they are not successful teaching them. In my district, the answer is often to label the child and place that child in a self-contained room. It gets rid of the regular education teacher's frustration, but is rarely best for the child. By excluding some children from the regular classroom we are segregating them- no other group (ethnic, racial, gender, etc.) is allowed to be segregated in public school- except children with disabilities. Another option would be to add adults in the classroom to support the children who need more assistance, especially those who need emotional support. If we put more money into our schools, especially in the hiring of quality adults who truly love children, teachers would have more energy for teaching and the children who struggle would feel more supported.
Thank you for your comment.
Thank you for your comment. It certainly does echo the thoughts and concerns of the teachers at our school.
Thank you for your comments!
Thank you for your comments! I too am an educator. I went into teaching because I wanted to make a difference, reach every child where they are. I am sorry that the parents above are experincing these issues and I feel even sadder for the children in those situations. However, please know that not every teacher is out to get the students! I personally make every effort to collaborate with parents and meet each child where they are. This is what I feel is a recipe for success!
In no way am I condoning the
In no way am I condoning the horrible and thoughtless actions of teachers who abuse, but I have to say that your remark about a system that favors teachers and does not listen to parents is ludicrous, but not for the reason you might think. In my experience, the opposite is true but only in certain situations. In the schools where I have taught, there are always parents who will be listened to, but they tend to be the rich or well connected parents. Their word trumps the teacher every time. Also, lets remember that Johnny and Suzie are not the perfect angels you think they are and it's not always the teacher's fault when a conflict of personality arises. That said, there are times when teachers are unfair and abusive but I would say that those times are dwarfed by the number of times that students recieve a safe, fair, quality education. If EVERY teacher picks on your child you should probably be asking yourself what kind of child you are raising.
I understand how you feel. My
I understand how you feel. My son was not diagnosed with Autism, severe speech delay and mild sensory processing disorder until last year. For two year's in public and at school I fought for my son because I had to. At one point a doctor suggested a residential home and that my son would never remember me after 3 months. My reply was this, I cried, pleaded and acted strong enough to take whatever comes our way, I begged them not to take my son away. Some of the words I remember using were "He needs his momma and I need him, without my son I have no life or reason, my boys are my only reason I am here and they need eachother too. Together my family can help my son. I still took an addtional year for the offical diganoses that took 5 minutes of the behavior doctor's time. I feel they are a wonderful, saving and brillant soal in the struggle with Autism (Dr. Lindsey, that was our angel figure with my son's struggle). The sympathetic doctor to this day, 3 years later will not look me in the eye when they see my son especially after my son gives them a hug. His school last year was great in regards to social progress but academically it was not working out as well in order for him to reach his potential. The private academy program that was thankfully saved by our governor's efforts and the help of beautiful corporations has been our saving grace for this year. We are not in the clear yet but we are not longer drowning, it’s now just a hill instead of the mountain side to overcome. My fear is the future my present is my peace. I hope your son has a wonderful set of teacher's and principals in the future, each year is a new chance for our children, special needs or typical they all deserved the best. Press on and stay encouraged as someone said to us in our time of tears when we thought the program was going to end just 2 weeks ago. There is still a need but hope never gives up, don't stop sticking up for the children because if we do, no one will stand up for them and they deserved all the love in the world from their teachers and everyone who sets their eyes on them, that's my philosophy.
My son had no physical,
My son had no physical, mental or emotional impairments. He was in a regular classroom when I began to noticed odd behaviors in him. He loved his kindergarten teacher and first grade was fun. He always like to dress nice and keep his hair neatly cut(some would take this as being uppity). However, by second or third grade everything began to change about him. He went from a young happy, excited boy who jumped from bed every morning eager to go to school. To someone who cried or pretended to be sick in order to avoid going to school. He went from a neat dresser to a sloppy dresser. He went from someone who loved getting all his homework answers correct to someone who purposely missed questions. He went from a little boy his older siblings loved to watch as he slept and laughed out in his sleep to someone who screamed out and had night terrors. I was a very active parent in school. Although, I was not always at his school. I also worked in the school system for a while. But even I had no idea the extent of what was happening to him. When he began to open up and talk, I went to the principal to tell her what was going on. Instead of her addressing the matter, she went to all the teachers and told them to watch what they did in front of my son, because he was a liar. However, most of what I learned was happening to my son came from a neighbor's child and friend of my son's who was in my son's classroom and not directly from my son. My neighbor's son was Korean and didn't have any problems with the teacher.
I finally learned that my son had been dragged down a hallway almost half the size of a football field flat on his back by a teacher, who dragged him by the strap of his backpack. I also found out the reason he began to purposely miss some of his homework questions because if he got all answers right, the teacher would accuse him of cheating. I also learned the teacher had incorporated the help of other students in the classroom to pick on my son.
Needless to say, this did great damage to my son and his self esteem that still reverberate unto this day. My son is now a 28 year old young man. But great damage was done to him back then in elementary school. Outwardly, he's achieved a lot and one a lot of great things in his life. At a very young age he developed his own website and attempted to start a small business online. He was in his teens at the time. He did graduate from high school and went on to college and even served four years in the U.S. Air Force. He has two college degrees and is working on a third. However, something was lost way back then. That happy little spontaneous boy, who jumped out of bed every morning and liked to dress neatly and get all the answers to questions was forever lost. I can see in him how he struggles with depression too and insecurity. He is married and he and his wife (also military) lives in another state. They both should graduate from college this spring. The only thing that saved my son from a total breaddown and total loss, to the degree that he was saved, was he did have a loving family who, to this day, care for him. I feel for all those other children who may not have anywhere to turn or anyone to turn to when they are abused either by family or in what should be a professional school sitting with educated professional. I feel for many children, especially poor, minority and especially minority black male children, a lot of their anti-social behavior that develop later in their teens can often be traced back to abuse in the school sitting.
This is just so heartbreaking
This is just so heartbreaking that an innocent child can be so harmed by a "professional" in a school setting where all kids should be safe and never fearful. I am paralyzed at the moment because I have a non-verbal beautiful, innocent disabled son who I fear may be getting physically abused at school. He cannot tell me what is going on, but I noticed he has slight bruising on his face a couple times when he returns from school. The first time it happened, he burst into tears the moment he saw me as he got off the school bus. I suspected the aide on the afternoon bus may have hit him in the face so he has not been back on that bus since. Today, I noticed slight brusing on his face again so he must have got that during school. I have been in his classroom as a volunteer so I know the other students do not have violent tendencies and am wondering if it's an aide or teacher in the classroom who is harming him. I am going to see the Superintendant of Schools tomorrow about this, but I have no proof other than the slight discolorations on his cheek. I just think he will contact the principal, the principal will contact the classroom teacher, the teacher will run it by the aides - no one will own up to it - end of story or worse, the perpetrator may start hitting him on the back of the head, etc. where there would be no evidence of physical bruising. HELP - what should I do in order to get to the bottom of this?
I graduated from college with
I graduated from college with a degree in English and minors in Secondary Education and Journalism. As a new teacher, the first year I taught 9th and 10th grade English, I had all the students who were repeating English 9 and 10, and a couple of the students had special needs (although no one told me about these beforehand). Although I was a caring person and really wanted to enable all my students to succeed, I was not prepared to deal with the varying needs of about 140 students, many of whom were already cynical about education and had suffered from abuses in the past.
One of the first days of school, the only non-white child in the class was behaving like he was under the influence of alcohol, so I asked him if he was drunk - oh, I so wish I had known he suffered from cerebral palsy!!! That was a quick lesson to me to be careful how I thought about my students. I so wish a course had been available in undergrad about recognizing and working with the variety of young people I had. Most teachers do not desire to inflict pain on their students, but all of us need to be made more aware of how to approach students whose behavior and needs fall outside of our personal realm of experience - such courses and seminars should be required in undergrad and not only in master's and doctoral-level courses. Much abuse could be prevented if teachers had the understanding and tools to work with diverse students from the start of their careers.
Thank you, Sean, for writing
Thank you, Sean, for writing this difficult piece. I was an educator in the special ed. department of 3 different schools during the last 34 years. In every school I witnessed "teachers" emotionally abusing students. As as teacher, I have always believed that my job was to help "fill the gaps" of my student's education. In every school, the administration corrected me. I was told to "help" them, but not to try to "fix" them. The school would loose funding if the number of students requiring special education went down.
I have left the teaching profession and now run my own school - where we are teaching to fill the gaps in every every student's education and giving them a new outlook on life and the future.
Any school that tolerates child abuse of any kind should be shut down! Every child is a gift to society. Teacher's must be about the task of finding the gift in each student.
As an educator in Ohio, I
As an educator in Ohio, I have personally seen and heard of too many special educators who have not had enough continuing education to meet the unique and demanding needs of special education students; students with significant behavioral difficulties or autism. These special educators do not understand or provide the myriad of antecedent, enviromental and positive interventions available that can assist special students. It is cruel and abusive to tie any young child into a restraining chair or to leave them to cry in a small room all alone. Yet that is what I have personally observed. The administration within the building and at the board of education know these practices are occurring and turn a blind eye. To speak up means loosing my teaching contract by turning against the administration and "established well regarded special education teachers". I have done what I can "quietly" do to attempt to change these situations. Special education teachers must be continually trained regarding current practices and research based interventions to assist special need students.
A comment on child abuse in
A comment on child abuse in the classroom:
Please note that corporal punishment as a means of classroom or school discipline is not illegal everywhere.
It is forbidden in some school districts, but not in others,
here in Pennsylvania, and many other states are the same. I do not know of a state in which corporal punishment ( meaning any physical punishment ) is legally forbidden in its entirety. Some of the people who don't want their own children "picked on" stand firmly in the way of completely outlawing this for everyone's children--other children, after all, might "need" to be "chastised" or "disciplined".
America, corporal punishment has been unlawful in our prisons for decades. Could we get it out of the schools, please.
The abuse that I saw in the
The abuse that I saw in the classroom today was horrible. I brought together three other nurses to do our mandated vision and hearing screenings of kindergarten, 2nd, and 5th graders in a "rural" school in Southern CA. So in defense of the teacher I can say that it is a very busy, somewhat chaotic time. I would like to say that this was the first time I had seen this teacher emotionally abuse her students, but it was not. It was a kindergarten class. It was very early in the morning, and they were visibly frightened of her voice. Some however, were, I believe, splitting from the reality of the room entirely. Frankly, I was frightened. I remember thinking, "And the parents have no idea what is happening to their child while they are here..." When I return to the school I will have to speak to the Principal about my observations. No more tolerance on my part!
They still have the Dummy
They still have the Dummy Room.
Only now it is called something more euphemistic, like the "Challenge Room" at my daughter's school (Jefferson County Schools, Colorado. They stink)
She has horror stories about this room. She got put there as punishment because she has Ausperger's and doesn't always fit in with the jocks and cheerleaders. She was bullied every year she was in Jeffco schools and they did not protect her. Columbine is a Jeffco school. Columbine happened because the school didn't stop bullying of Harris and Klebold by jocks who had the run of the school.
I work with schools and we definitely have problems with illegal use of restraints, corporal punishment, and other student abuse issues.
Colorado still allows corporal punishment in its public schools. I know of half a dozen rural schools who still practice this barbaric, unintelligent abuse on kids.
There are only two professions in the US where you can legally beat someone with a paddle...
...Principal and Prostitute.
I am a retired social worker
I am a retired social worker who has been a substitute teacher for the past four years in the Chicago metropolitan area. I can attest to the fact that physical and psychological abuse is unfortunately perpetrated on too many children by too many teachers both in the city and in the suburbs. There is no excuse for physical or verbal abuse, no matter how good or bad the school, the system, or the children are. Children need to have basic human rights' protection.
Teachers who belittle their students in front of the class, insult their intelligence, or tolerate abuse of students by other students (yes, Columbine is the classic example)are failing their students. Teachers who resort to physical punishment should be charged with assault and battery. Unfortunately, there is a wall of silence in schools and in the profession. It is education's dirty little secret that professionals will not challenge their peers. This has to stop. The teachers know who the dysfunctional teachers are. The good teachers need to stand up and protect the students. And they need to stand up against the principal if necessary to protect children from abuse.
Teachers are mandated reporters of child abuse, just like doctors and nurses. They need to take their role seriously and protect the children in their school's care. Stand up and be counted. Maybe parents don't realize it, but they can also report child abuse by a teacher to the child welfare agency which has to legally investigate every complaint. Stand up and be counted. Protect your child. Change schools if necessary.
I have a special needs grandchild and our family has stood up for him every day, every year. We work cooperatively with the school personnel and have a good relationship, but we have worked at it and advocated for him. It is the easy way out for the teaching profession to blame the student for not learning instead of looking at the methods for teaching that are not succeeding. Speak up, stand up, complain, advocate, don't stop - you will be saving a child.
Focus on the educational welfare of one student at a time. Don't be sidetracked by the arguments that "nothing can be done." We have the greatest educational system in the world, but it can always be better, and it can always be made to work better for one student at a time. I know from experience and history that every time the system is made to get better for one student, it gets better for all students.
I work for the chicago public
I work for the chicago public schools at michele clark magnet high school. I work with special neeeds/special ed students. The problem is with the bogus IEP's that some of the students have. We have one student with cerebal palsy non verbal but when the new teacher was reviewing the IEP's they had him as a verbal student. There were several flaws in all of the student's IEP's. My first year I sat in om student's eval but did not know what the process was about and saw the anguish of the parents and how they feel about the whole process.We also need to have compassion for the family also.
This a particularly difficult
This a particularly difficult topic for me, as I have been both a victim of classroom abuse, and a parent of a child who was abused in the classroom. As a child, I had decent grades until 5th grade. The teacher was a gruff old WWII vet who had a reputation for hitting kids. When I began having math difficulties, he became verbally abusive, belittling me in front of the class. I began to miss assignments because I felt stupid, and then began trying to fake my way out of classes. I developed a pre-ulcerous condition due to stress. Mind you, he NEVER touched me. He did use verbal aggression, as well as displays of brutality toward others. The only thing that really changed the situation was the War. He had sustained a serious injury in the conflict, and the steel plate in his leg needed to be removed. He went out for the last half of the year. The substitute who took his spot took more interest in my problems and helped me through the remaineder of the year. I never did do well in math.
Years later, I am a Child Psychologist. My son is diagnosed with Pervasive Developmental Disorder. A lot like Asperger's Disorder. We have been extremely active participants in his IEP process, and they both love and hate us at the school district. In 3rd grade he was transfered with his classmates to a new school. His teacher, who did not have the training to deal with a PDD child, ended up causing severe psychological distress for my boy, and he was yelled at frequently.He went from jumping out of bed for school, to crying when it was time to get on the bus. There were several times we were called into the school to help control our boy. We had words with (and at) the teacher, administration, and staff of the school. To the teacher's defense, he was not an ogre. He was ignorant. It took great courage on his part, but he finally approached me and confessed his frustration. Although it was difficult, I worked through my own issues, and helped him on focusing on stratagies that would work with my son. The final half of that year went much more smoothly, and the teacher still calls to thank me. My son is now in 5th grade and literally can't wait to go to school.
I cry as I write this.
Proving Emotional Abuse is
Proving Emotional Abuse is difficult and that is what abusive teachers count on when they torment their students in collaborative classrooms where teachers are supposed to be trained in special education issues. To go to the level of the child by rushing to call the parent of a disabled child and stating the child 'won' after seeing a big smile on their face after being told by the child that their parents changed their schedule back to the original way (exploratory Spanish versus Regular Spanish) makes one wonder where the level of maturity is with teachers who are supposed to be trained to work with children who have 504 Plans and I.E.P.'s when they purposely control when a child will get a break, take water, go to the bathroom or go to a safe place for students who have it stipulated on their plans as accommodations and modifications. To tell a child to 'get out' of the classroom and constantly write them up for referrals and the 'Intervention Room' when they don't want to implement alternate methods of teaching and coping skills for both themselves and for the students is blatantly abusive and often backed up by the Principal, Social Worker, Psychologist and Committee on Special education as well as district. There are places a family can go for advocacy in such cases, beginning with your local S.E.P.T.A (Special Education PTA); the U.S. Dep't of Educ. Ofc. of Spec. Educ. & Rehab. Svcs.: 1-202-245-7587; No Child Left Behind: 518-474-3862; V.E.S.I.D.- 518-474-2714 & for Mediation- 518-476-7462. Check your local area as well, like Long Island Advocacy Council for Nassau & Suffolk Counties of NYS; Advocates for Children of NY, Inc.- 800-388-2014. Hope this testimony and resources help.