How do we keep track of different external pressures on teaching? How do we keep track of political goals? How do we balance our own beliefs with those around us?
Groups:
Recent comments: General Discussions Discussion Area
| Comment | Recent activity | Title |
|---|---|---|
| It is but reasonable for you | 3 weeks 2 days ago | David Benowitz |
| Video:John O'Flahavan, discusses a related topic about the valid | 15 weeks 2 days ago | Which Video/Which Topics/Which Surveys/Which Issues Were Hard to Work Through? Why? |
| Response-Race is not everything | 15 weeks 2 days ago | Which Video/Which Topics/Which Surveys/Which Issues Were Hard to Work Through? Why? |
| Reaction to The Common Beliefs Survey | 15 weeks 2 days ago | Which Video/Which Topics/Which Surveys/Which Issues Were Hard to Work Through? Why? |
| Meaning of Race | 16 weeks 6 days ago | Changes in Thinking After Watching the First Few Videos |


Comments
Rubenstein: Reflection 6
Reflection 6
The politics of education are very intriguing. I think it is very difficult to keep an objective mind in teaching, because at the end of the day it is a very emotional job. As the academic year wraps up I more fully believe that the foundational element of a school is the relationship between the teachers and students. That is the guiding principle of classroom culture - how a teacher relates to a student. I remember back when Prof Tejeda talked about how intimate the educational experience can be. I did not understand it back then, but I defnitely understand it now. Throughout this year, I've grown to feel like my students are my children. I have a son and the feeling is very similar. I want both my son and all my students to thrive in the real world. I want my son and my students to develop an internal intellectual curiosity that will allow them to enjoy going to museums, reading books and learning random biology, math and physics principles that explain the mysteries of the Earth. I really want these for all my students and my son. So given this emotional connection, it is difficult to stay objective through the many political turns education is being pushed through nowadays.
So I think the best way to stay as objective as possible is to be as informed as possible. Most importantly, as a teacher, to learn about labor history and what have been the ups and downs of the profession. Also, to think about the long term effects of the decisions that are made. And lastly, have exposure to international school systems. I have learned a lot from reflecting on my schooling experience in Guatemala and what I learn from what my cousins tell me.
This week many teachers at Wilson learned that they were being displaced. Needless to say this has caused a lot of emotional turmoil for everyone - all teachers and their students. I can't help but feel that in this scenario NO ONE wins. Teachers lose a school they are invested in, students lose a teacher they know and care for. What is good for a teacher, is good for a student. That is why as teachers, we should continue to advocate for our profession and for continual training and time for professional development, because ultimately we know it benefits our students. I don't think teachers should be shy about demanding better pay, more supplies, smaller class sizes, this ALL benefits the students ... I'm infinitely perplexed that there is not a stronger counter narrative to the myth of the 'bad teachers' (I know they are out there, but they are not most of the people I've met). I've made this argument before, but I think creating this counter narrative and movement would greatly benefit us all --- teachers and students.
Reflection#6 Carlos
Definitely being as informed as possible is the best way to stay objective. These political issues directly affect us teachers and as a result, affect our students. "we should continue to advocate for our profession....because ultimately we know it benefits our students."
Eben's response
I'm so happy to hear that you've found that intimate connection with your students--the one that Tejera talked about in the beginning of the program. Teaching is definitely a very emotional and demanding job, especially in the current political climate. We've got to do everything that we can to advocate for our students--to ensure that they have a quality education. What you're going through in Wilson also happened in Lincoln. We lost the KIA grant for next year, which means that 60% of the faculty will be displaced. And the dumb thing about this whole policy is that, as you said, no one wins. Without the funding, the school will only get worse, which in turn will lead to even less funding. It's a downward spiral to the black hole of charter schools, which I'm beginning to resent more day after day.
Reflection#6
There
are a few recurring issues that today’s educational system seem to be fixated
on. For example, there is an overwhelming emphasis placed on a school’s
Academic Performance Index (API), Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP), No Child Left
Behind Act (NCLB), California Standardized Test (CST), high-stakes test in
general, teaching to the test, teacher evaluations and accountability. In fact,
in the United States, routine
high-stakes testing is used to rank students, teachers, and schools. Many politicians and policymakers today tend to link
school accountability and school performance. There are School
Accountability Report Cards which are issued annually for each school in the State
of California and provide an assessment of selected conditions related to the
school, its resources, its successes, and the areas in which improvements may
be needed. Moreover, these reports, along with NCLB, also have a purpose to gauge the progress of schools and
districts toward helping all students achieve grade level proficiency in
Reading and Math. A school must meet specific targets under NCLB on
standardize tests and graduation rates for all students and for certain groups such
as economically disadvantaged students, students with disabilities, English learners,
and students in different ethnic groups. When a school fails to meet AYP for
two consecutive years, the school undergoes a Program Improvement (PI) process.
These type of schools are now considered Title 1 schools and an intervention is
designed to help the schools meet its requirements. Parents are also notified
when a school enters PI status. Overall, at this point in my career, I am not
looking forward to deal with any of these endless politics issues around
education. In fact, if and when appropriate, I prefer to stay as far away from
it as possible while of course staying up to date and informed about the
political arena; if that makes any sense.
Geo's Reflection
I'm so glad you outlined all those issues and said people were "fixated" on them. Recently I've been thinking about how standards test do exactly what we are NOT suppose to do as educators and that is reduce students into demographics, statistics and other numbers. For my activity recently I had lunch with a student and learned a whole lot about this students individual passion, interests and dreams, yet a standards test will never catch his individuality and imagination ...
I think its impossible to stay out of thosep politics as they affect our every day life in education.
my comment on your comment from commenting on my reflection.
This is an issue that I will continue to struggle with. I need to force myself to pay attention to these political issues.
Geo's reflection
Nicely put Geo, but how
will you stay informed? Will you watch the news or visit education websites?
And another question I have is “how can you stay away from politics if it
directly involves you and your students? Good job that you already recognize some
of these politics and the need for them to be addressed properly.
Reflection 7
“Who is to say
that robbing a people of its language is less violent that war?” – Ray Gwyn
Smith (Lee et all,
pg. 145)
This quote
speaks out to me because it is a reminder that language – practices, beliefs,
and values – is the foundation of our lives.
When addressing the many external pressures that teachers face, it is
important to be mindful of the basic core principles for why we teach and the
justification for why we teach the way we do.
When we have a solid platform of education principles, we can develop an
organized system that categorizes the different pressures based on priority and
where they fit into improving our teaching to give our students a better
education. My mission is to improve the
quality of life for my students. As a
teacher everything I do, including the day to day decision making, advocating
political and instructional strategies and policies over others, and finding
balance inside and outside of my classroom, is in relation to my mission. By having a core principle to look to, I find
that I am able to find solid footing and rebalance myself when I am pushed and
pulled by the different external pressures. It is easy to lose sight of how to reach a
compromise when there are so many additional challenges facing teachers. Education is an emotional job that many
teachers get into to educate students for future jobs and life skills. Unfortunately, teachers also have to abide by
the decisions made by policy makers who do not understand the intricacies of
teaching. This gap of knowledge allows
policymakers to make short-sighted decisions, of course in the best interest of
the students that actually achieve the opposite. To balance our beliefs with others it is
necessary for teachers to communicate to the general public and policy makers,
so that the people making the decisions that we as teachers will have to
enforce will be better educated to make better decisions. As teachers, I find that it is not only our
responsibility to educate our students, but also to educate our student’s
families, the community, and the people who make decisions that control all these
areas.
Libby DeLacy's Response
April,
I like the idea of grounding yourself in a belief. It does make it easier to prioritize things. It's nice to have a touchstone when you feel like you are being pulled in a million directions.
I agree that is a shame policymakers often push legislation that harm students in the long run. I also agree that only through advocacy will we be able to address this. Knowing people are so busy, what would you suggest to get people interested in advocacy? I worry that the belief most people ground themselves with is something about surviving. I fear people don't have the bandwidth to advocate for things like we need. Only when things get really bad, and people are backed into a corner, will they be motivated to make a difference.
Discussion 6
One way of keeping track with different external pressures on teaching is to stay current with the news. We need to be informed of the current political climate in the education field, particularly with the agendas that drive the actions of every dominant party. For instance, many republicans at this point wish to charter off low-performing schools because they know that the schools in their district won't be adversely affected. Being educated on these types of issues allows us to be an advocate for what we believe is right--which is the ultimate goal, in my opinion.
it's also important for us to have meaningful discussions with those people in the field. Many of the information in the news can be skewed to one side, or innoculated to avoid criticism. By talking with current educators, we are able to find out what these issues mean at a personal level--why they really matter to people. For instance, if it weren't for the fact that we're currently looking for steady jobs, I might be part of the hordes of people out there who demonize the unions. Or, if it weren't for the fact that Lincoln lost their Kia grant, I might've not developed that empathy for schools who are loosing funding; like many aloof politicians, I may just turn the other way and say that those schools had it coming to them. It wasn't really until I became personally vested in the issue that I began considering other perspectives.
Reflection#6 Eben
Eben, your reflection really made me think of my own biases. I am really struggling with this whole 'politics' theme. One side of me wants no part of this political arena but you make a good point that beng educated on these types of issues allows us to be an advocate for what we believe is right and it's also important for us to have a meaningful discussions with people in the field. Thanks for sharing!
-geo
reflection
wow, I'm so glad you had that change in perspective. I'd say that all news is always skewed to tell a particular story, so its important to get to know a topic in depth before forming an opinion about it as you did.
I'm glad you see that Lincoln, Wilson and all these other comprehensive schools with low APIs are not 'failing' as the test scores would leaad us to believe. BUt they are thriving in each person's ability to survive the many obstacles they face, but of course, a standards test woudl never capture this human dimension.
Didn't we already respond to
Didn't we already respond to this in class?