Inspiration Knows No Gender

"Share
Printer-friendly versionPrinter-friendly version

When the Dallas Texas Public Schools District decided to show its fifth-graders Red Tails, an action-adventure film based on the Tuskegee pilots who formed the country’s first black aerial combat unit, it was a tremendous idea. The district felt students would be inspired by the story of these men who fought segregation, integrated the Army and were trained as combat pilots for the United States during WWII.

But when district officials learned that the theater was too small to accommodate all the fifth-graders, they made a dreadful decision to only allow boys to benefit from the inspiration the Tuskegee Airmen offer. The incident became an example of what holds us all back.

A district spokesman justified the school’s decision by explaining that district leaders “thought boys would enjoy the movie more than girls.” Female students were given the opportunity to view the film Akeelah and the Bee, an inspirational story about a young girl who wins a spelling bee.

But inspiration comes in a variety of forms and speaks to us all in different ways. Making determinations along gender lines does not honor our unique interests and abilities; it only makes flawed assumptions.

Take, for example, Texas native Bessie Coleman, the first African-American woman to earn an international pilot’s license. She was inspired by the war stories of male pilots during WWI. She decided, in 1918, that she wanted to fly.

Coleman had grown up poor. She was educated in a one-room schoolhouse. As an adult, she longed to escape the segregated South for greater opportunities. But even in Chicago, the world around her determined that only certain careers would be open to her. She worked as a manicurist and as manager of a chili parlor, but she envisioned more.

She was denied entry into American flight schools because of both her race and gender. But Coleman saved her money, learned to speak French and, with the help of a wealthy friend, went to France to learn to fly. In June 1921, she earned her pilot’s license. She had a career as a show pilot.

A handful of other women had also earned pilot’s licenses. A decade before, Harriet Quimby became the first woman in the United States and the second woman in the world, to earn a pilot’s license. A French baroness was the first woman in the world to earn a pilot’s license in 1910. In 1929, the transcontinental air race was open to women for the first time. Twenty women pilots entered the race from Santa Monica, Calif., to Cleveland, Ohio.

These women found inspiration in the stories and dreams of others, often of different gender, race or religion. They rebelled against stereotypes. That’s inspiration that defies gender. As we enter Women’s History Month, we should remember that stories of courage and firsts are not to be categorized and prepackaged.


The Tuskegee Airmen, pilots of the 332nd Fighter Group in 1942. Photo credits: National Archives.

When we remember the story of the Tuskegee Airmen, we can also note that it was Mary McLeod Bethune, educator and sole female member of President Franklin Roosevelt’s “black cabinet,” who worked to make sure the Civilian Pilot Training Program was offered at historically black colleges and universities. In 1939, aviation programs were established first at West Virginia State College and later at the Tuskegee Institute. Bethune was also able to secure funds to expand Tuskegee’s program in 1941 with the help of her friend, Eleanor Roosevelt.

It’s important to share these stories with all of our students. They need to know that obstacles have come before and may come again. They need to learn despite naysayers, it’s still great to work toward a dream—even if no one who looks exactly like them has done it before. Inspiration has no gender. It has no race. When we witness courage, it makes us all stronger.

Williamson is associate editor of Teaching Tolerance.

Comments

Thank you for voicing this so

Submitted by Julia Mims e on 28 February 2012 - 7:21am.

Thank you for voicing this so eloquetly, we do discriminate. We do not want to look at the fact that there are those that feel that everyone needs to be in 'their' place. When will we as a nation get bold enough to see that we are all the same save for the paint on our 'houses' being different shades.... Teaching Tolerance is something that begins at home teaching not only tolerance but respect.... We have a lot of work to do...

When I saw this email and the

Submitted by Sandi Milavec on 28 February 2012 - 11:37am.

When I saw this email and the headline-I knew before reading the article that it had to have happened in the south and when I found out that it was Texas-it really made sense. So ridiculous and a very poor decision based on gender stereotypes!!

Why would you think this

Submitted by Cat on 28 February 2012 - 1:13pm.

Why would you think this incident would have to have happened in the south?

Yes, indeed. Texas (and the

Submitted by Dave Crafts on 28 February 2012 - 2:10pm.

Yes, indeed. Texas (and the south) has a long history of poor decisions and unjustified behavior in regard to injustice and discrimination. However, we need to be careful and not respond to stereotypes with stereotypes. Let's not jump to conclusions and make generalized statements about an entire population/state. In order to become a more just society we need to rise above.

Sandi-Maybe you should read

Submitted by Anne on 29 February 2012 - 11:16am.

Sandi-Maybe you should read the Teaching Tolerance website more often. It might help you get over your extreme prejudices. I would be curious to know when your state was first run by a female; Texas was 1933.

When I read this report I

Submitted by Rick Fleming on 28 February 2012 - 1:00pm.

When I read this report I thought to myself, if I had done this on my district, I would be run out of town on a rail. Equality in thought and experience is crucial to the development of all students.

I tend to disagree with the

Submitted by Maynard Thomas on 28 February 2012 - 1:27pm.

I tend to disagree with the contention of the school district that boys "would enjoy the movie more than girls". I served in the armed services during the Vietnam conflict, 1968-70, when the draft was in utilized. Presently we utilize an, "all volunteer military", which includes women. The notion that boys wold enjoy serving in the present day military but girls would not is ludicrous. Women serve along side men in today's complete spectrum of the armed services. The fact that during a time of all volunteer military, which includes women in all branches illustrates inspiration is shared by both genders to serve the United States of America.

Thank you for sharing this.

Submitted by Chris Bergerson on 28 February 2012 - 1:46pm.

Thank you for sharing this. The stories of the women who flew the big bombers across the US and around the world during WWII is amazing as well. I met several of them with their husbands when I lived in Hawaii, and the stories they told were hair raising. The women not only flew aircraft to deliver them to the men, but flew them dragging targets across the skies for artillery target practice. In this day and age where women are serving in the military, making a decision like this for girls is truely backwards--and does a huge diservice to our country as well. The school should get a copy of the movie and show it to the whole class. I'll bet Mr. Speilberg could facilitate that.

Well done Lisa. It's

Submitted by Louise on 28 February 2012 - 3:11pm.

Well done Lisa. It's infuriating how many forces seem to be trying to turn the clock backward for women; legislation to ban access to birth control, etc. Phoenix, Arizona banning Chicano studies, which of course, includes both genders. When it comes to civil rights, I guess we can never rest or consider a battle won.

Inspiring our young women to

Submitted by Stephen Siegel on 28 February 2012 - 7:14pm.

Inspiring our young women to enlist in the US military should be a top priority in school, so I'm surprised Texas let them off so easy. Maybe it's not too late to show another action war movie that shows people of color killing and being killed. What about "Platoon?" Other than the high rates of sexual assault, a military career is a great opportunity for women to meet people from diverse cultures and destroy their lives. It's a shame that they missed out on such an inspiration and had to settle for a movie about a spelling bee.

Do you suppose that girls and

Submitted by Tomas Heikkala on 28 February 2012 - 8:57pm.

Do you suppose that girls and boys would like to get down to a little real truth about war. Glorifying the world wide disaster know as WW2 is a little short sighted to say the least. 50 million people died during that grotesque event. As a vet of the Vietnam disaster, who grew up blinded by the events of WW 2, I had to find out why our government would take up where the French left off. In the process I found out that all wars are about imperialism/colonialism. The good that comes from them is only incidental to its real purposes.
Think I am wrong? Do some serious study and see if I am not telling the truth.

I think that all teachers

Submitted by Cesar Guerrero Chalas on 1 March 2012 - 11:17am.

I think that all teachers have a lot to learn from this article. United States is a multicultural country and we need to teach and inspire all ethnic groups. By doing this, this nation will be stonger and better. Our duty is to expand the possibilities of students and to make sure that they benefit from their potential.

Could anyone give me

Submitted by Homeschool teacher on 2 March 2012 - 10:24am.

Could anyone give me suggestions about how to obtain a copy of the film? Thanks!